Religious Accommodation After Groff v. DeJoy: What Changed for Pennsylvania Workers?

Religious Accommodation After Groff v. DeJoy: What Changed for Pennsylvania Workers?

Key Takeaway:

The Supreme Court’s decision in Groff v. DeJoy strengthened religious accommodation protections for Pennsylvania workers by making it harder for employers to justify denying accommodation requests. Employers must now show that a requested accommodation would impose a substantial burden on the overall operation of their business, rather than relying on minor costs or inconveniences. 

In Pennsylvania and across the United States, employees have the right to practice their religion without facing unfair treatment at work. Federal and state laws protect workers from religious discrimination and require employers to consider reasonable accommodations for sincerely held religious beliefs. However, the rules for determining when an employer can deny an accommodation changed significantly after the landmark Supreme Court ruling in Groff v. DeJoy. The outcome of this case makes it more difficult for employers to claim that accommodating an employee’s religious beliefs would create an undue hardship. If your employer denies your request for a religious accommodation, do not hesitate to contact an experienced employment lawyer.

What the Supreme Court Decided in Groff v. DeJoy

This landmark case involved Gerald Groff, who was an Evangelical Christian who worked as a mail carrier in rural Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Groff held a deeply rooted belief that Sunday was the Sabbath, which is a day for rest and worship. However, after signing a major delivery contract with Amazon, the United States Postal Service (USPS) started delivering packages on Sundays. Groff requested an exemption from Sunday work and offered to take extra shifts on Saturdays, holidays, and evenings to make up for the inconvenience of having to reshuffle work schedules. Initially, the post office tried to accommodate Groff by transferring him to another post office. Eventually, however, that location also began delivering packages on Sunday.

Scheduling conflicts continued, and Groff received administrative warnings and disciplinary actions. Knowing he would eventually be fired, Groff resigned and decided to sue the postal service under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, citing religious discrimination. Initially, the lower courts ruled against Groff, relying on an earlier Supreme Court decision that allowed employers to deny religious accommodations if they created more than a minimal cost or burden. However, after appealing the decision, the Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the previous interpretation of undue hardship was inaccurate, and that employers may not deny religious accommodations simply because they create a minor inconvenience or additional expense. 

The New “Substantial Increased Cost” Standard

The “substantial increased cost” standard refers to the legal standard established by the U.S. Supreme Court regarding workplace religious accommodations under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Under this standard, an employer can deny an employee’s religious accommodation request only by demonstrating that granting it would result in substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its business. The following are the main changes under the new standard:

  • Replacement of the “de minimis” threshold. For close to 50 years, employers only had to show that an accommodation would cause “more than a de minimis (minimal) cost” to claim an undue hardship. Groff v. DeJoy clarified that a minimal burden is not enough to deny a request.
  • Contextual evaluation. Courts and employers must assess the burden in the context of the employer’s specific nature, size, and operational budget. A cost that might create a substantial hardship for a small business may not meet the threshold for a large corporation.
  • Impact beyond pure expenses. Cost includes non-financial impacts, including operational disruption, provided those administrative burdens directly translate into substantial practical costs for the business. Co-worker hostility or bias toward a religious practice cannot be used to claim an undue hardship.

Common Religious Accommodations at Work

Following the Supreme Court’s decision in Groff v. DeJoy, employers have had to accommodate a wider range of religious requests. The following are examples of religious accommodations that employers are expected to allow:

  • Sabbath and holy day scheduling adjustments. Employers are expected to exhaust operational adjustments before denying schedule-based requests, including:
    – Excused absences for observances. Granting time off or unpaid leave for holy days or religious observances.
    – Shift changes and voluntary substitutions. Facilitating voluntary shift trading between co-workers or reallocating schedules.
    – Flexible hours. Adjusting start and end times to allow employees to leave early before sunset for Sabbath or religious services.
  • Daily prayer breaks and space. Employers are required to allow the following accommodations for daily prayer breaks:
    – Short break adjustments. Allowing flexible 10- to 15-minute breaks during the workday for daily prayer or meditation.
    – Dedicated quiet space. Designating a clean, private, non-restroom room in the facility for prayer or quiet devotion.
  • Dress, grooming, and religious symbols. Employers must allow the following dress code accommodations:
    – Head covering and attire. Permitting exceptions to uniform policies for religious garments, including a hijab, yarmulke, or modesty skirts.
    – Facial hair and hairstyles. Allowing exceptions to hair length policies for employees whose faith prohibits cutting hair or shaving, including Sikh, Orthodox Jewish, or Rastafarian traditions.
    – Jewelry and sacred items. Allowing employees to wear religious jewelry, including a crucifix, Kabbalah red string bracelet, or a Sikh Kara bracelet.
  • Job task reassignment and conscientious objections. If an employee’s sincerely held religious beliefs conflict with a specific, discrete work duty, employers must explore partial reassignments or duty swaps.
    – Conscientious task relief. Excusing an employee from performing specific tasks that violate their faith by assigning those tasks to a co-worker.
    – Excusal from religious invocation. Permitting employees to opt out of workplace religious invocations, prayers, or sectarian events held during company meetings.
  • Dietary practices and work facilities.
    – Dietary options at company events. Providing kosher, halal, vegetarian, or vegan options at employer-provided meals or catered events.
    – Storage and breakroom accommodations. Allowing separate refrigerator space or microwave access for employees who maintain strict dietary laws, like keeping kosher or halal food separate.

How to Request an Accommodation and What to Do if Denied

If you would like to request a religious accommodation in the workplace, it is highly recommended that you take the following steps:

  • Put the request in writing. Send an email or formal letter to your direct supervisor or to Human Resources.
  • State the conflict clearly. Explain that a specific job requirement or workplace policy conflicts with your sincerely held religious beliefs or practices.
  • Propose a solution. Offer one or more solutions, including modifications to the dress code, adjusted break times for prayer, or swapping shifts.
  • Keep detailed records. Save copies of the initial request, follow-up emails, and your employer’s responses to your request.


If your employer denies your request for religious accommodations, there are additional steps you can take to ensure that your request is approved, including the following:

  • Request the reason for the denial in writing. If the request was denied in person, send a follow-up email confirming the denial and ask for specific reasons why your request was denied.
  • Engage in the “interactive process.” Employers are expected to communicate with you and explore possible options that would satisfy your religious need without creating undue conflict for the employer.
  • Document everything. Keep detailed records, including dates and times of all conversations, exact quotes from your employer about why your request was denied, and copies of written requests, refusal letters, and performance reviews.
  • File an official complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) or the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission (PHRC). 
  • Contact an experienced employment lawyer who will help you navigate the process of filing a complaint and ensure that your legal rights are protected.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):

Are employers required to grant an employee’s exact requested accommodation?

No. Employers are required to provide a reasonable accommodation, not necessarily the employee’s preferred accommodation. If an employer offers an alternative accommodation that effectively resolves the religious conflict without causing undue hardship, this fulfills the statutory obligation under Title VII. 

Can customer preferences or co-worker hostility justify denying a religious accommodation?

No. According to the Supreme Court, bias or hostility toward a particular religion cannot be used to establish undue hardship. Hardship driven by religious prejudice does not count as a legitimate business burden. 

Does co-worker burden or scheduling disruption qualify as an “undue hardship”?

Co-worker impact can only contribute to undue hardship if it directly affects the conduct of the business. An employer cannot rely solely on the fact that an accommodation forces co-workers to pick up extra shifts or work overtime. Employers must evaluate alternative solutions, such as voluntary shift swaps or operational adjustments, before claiming undue hardship.

Our Experienced Philadelphia Employment Lawyers at The Gold Law Firm P.C. Represent Clients in Religious Accommodation Cases

If your employer denied your request for a religious accommodation, do not hesitate to contact our Philadelphia employment lawyers at The Gold Law Firm P.C. We will determine whether your legal rights have been violated, help you navigate the claims process, and negotiate the religious accommodations that meet your needs. To schedule a free consultation, call today at 215-569-1999 or contact us online. With office locations in Philadelphia and Malvern, Pennsylvania, Pennsauken, New Jersey, and New York, New York, we proudly serve clients in the surrounding areas. *NYC, Pennsauken, and Malvern offices are by appointment only.