Philly Police Seek Reinstatement After Offensive Facebook Posts

July 1st, 2020

Sidney L. Gold was recently quoted in an article addressing the Philadelphia police officers who wanted their jobs reinstated after punishment due to racist social media posts. In June 2019, racist and violent Facebook posts by police offers were made public and started a wave of protests across the United States. The Plain View Project, a database of public Facebook posts and comments made by current and former police officers, enabled the public to do their own research on what officers are saying in their neighborhoods.

In Philadelphia, many uniformed officers were punished for their online conduct and the content they posted. Now, a year later, those officers who were punished are appealing their discipline through the police union’s arbitration process. The officers who voluntarily left the department are also appealing their punishment, despite the chance of permanent termination.

Due to the demonstrations that occurred in 2019, the Philadelphia Police Department sought to terminate 15 police officers for their online content. Eleven out of the 15 officers resigned or retired instead of facing formal termination; the other officers were given month-long suspensions. All officers involved have filed grievances to try and get their jobs back. A grievance arbitration is a common process for police departments but it is also quite controversial. This process has led to the rehiring and badge returns of fired officers, despite their past wrongdoings. Grievance arbitration has become a topic of conversation as of recent due to the Black Lives Matter movement.

The Federal Order of Police (FOP) argues that the resignations of the police officers from 2019 were forced dismissals. The past Police Commissioner framed the resignations as more effective than terminations because, under Pennsylvania labor law, unionized employees do not usually grieve resignation or retirement. The officers who filed grievances claimed that their actions were a type of constructive discharge, where the only choice was to resign.

Proving this argument in court is extremely difficult. Sidney L. Gold stated that it is very restrictive and that the officers would need to prove their working conditions were intolerable, that they complained to an employer to improve those conditions, and that those efforts failed. The appeal process is still ongoing with many obstacles ahead for the officers who desire to be reinstated. To read more about the investigation and Sidney L. Gold’s legal perspective on the case, click here.

View All Practices
Sidney L. Gold SuperLawyer 16 years
Top Rated Lawyers Legal Leaders
ASLA 2019 badge
ATA Lifetime
BBB Rating
Best Lawyers Award Badge
Best Lawyers Award Badge
Institute Visionary Circle Badge
Best Employment lawyers in Philadelphia
2019 American Trail Lawyers badge
Lead Counsel Rated
life time achievement
million dollar advocates badge
AV Peer Review Rated
Philly Happening
Top one badge
martindale hubbell 2019
super lawyers badge
Gold American Registry 2020
© 2020 Sidney L. Gold and Associates, P.C. All rights reserved. [ Site Map | Privacy Policy ]

Attorney Advertising Materials. Sidney L. Gold is responsible for the content of this website. This website is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.

* The awards and accolades displayed on this website were issued to the attorneys, or the entire law firm by the respective providers of these honors. They are as follows, Avvo Inc., Super Lawyers®, Martindale Hubbell Peer Review Rated, ASLA 2019 Top 100 Lawyers, Million Dollar Advocates Forum, Legal Leaders Top Rated Lawyers 2018, Bar Register Preeminent Lawyer 2019, Happening List Winner 2019, BBB Accredited Business, National Association of Distinguished Counsel Top 1 Percent 2017, America's Top 100 Attorneys, The Employee Rights Advocacy Institute for law and policy 2017-2018, Best Lawyers 2019, Lead Counsel Rated, Top Employment Lawyers in Philadelphia, Association of American Trial Lawyers Top 100 in 2019 and Martindale Hubbell Client Champion Silver 2019. No aspect of these advertisements have been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey.

A Message to Our Customers About Coronavirus COVID-19:

A Message to Our Clients About Coronavirus COVID-19:

At Sidney L. Gold & Associates, P.C. we view the safety and well-being of our clients, staff and business partners as our highest priority.

The situation regarding the COVID-19 virus is continually changing, and we are following all recommended guidelines to stay healthy.

Currently, our business will remain open to serve your needs.

We are happy to arrange for phone or video consultations should you have any concerns about keeping your scheduled appointments with us. We are also able to exchange documents via secure drives or email.

Should you have any concerns regarding an upcoming meeting with us, please contact us online or call 215-569-1999.

We are continuing to fight on behalf of our clients and that we are all able to handle things even if mandated by the government that we work remotely.

Thank you and take care.